Looking into the future, imagining different scenarios, identifying choices, and exploring tradeoffs -- all to ensure a sustainable future for the Upper Floridan Aquifer and the regional economy -- can seem overwhelming. How will we know what scenarios to consider? How will we know that the information we are building our scenarios on is sound? How will we explore situations and potential tradeoffs from different perspectives?
One major objective of the project is to bring stakeholders and experts throughout the region together to explore these and other questions.
Stakeholder collaboration and contributions will be achieved through:
- Project Advisory Committee (PAC)
- Stakeholder members engaging in the Participatory Modeling Process (PMP Stakeholders)
- Stakeholder surveys and focus groups
Participatory Modeling Process (PMP)
Project models will allow stakeholders to explore the tradeoffs on future land and water use between agricultural, economic, and environmental issues. If project scientists were to build and run their models using data from secondary sources and without stakeholder involvement, they would run the risk that the outputs might inaccurately represent the realities across the region. Failure to consider stakeholder perspectives might result in findings that are of little relevance or use to local decision-makers. As part of a “participatory modeling process”, we are looking to stakeholders to inform the model development and propose and analyze alternative future scenarios.
The goal of the Participatory Modeling Process (PMP) is to create a venue for scientists and stakeholders to come together and share perspectives, identify knowledge gaps, and create holistic, legitimate visions of the future. The group will generate and discuss scenarios, tradeoffs, and incentives related to current and future land use, water management, and rural economic development.
Project modelers will generate a series of scenarios (pictures of future land and water use and management) at both the farm and regional scales across two watersheds - in Florida and Georgia. Informed by biophysical, economic and land-use model results, these scenarios will enable discussions around a range of impacts that different management practices and land uses may have on water quality, water quantity, and economics. In addition, the scenarios will enable dialog about the tradeoffs among land management and land use choices and the kinds of incentives that would be needed to sustain healthy rural economic and environmental systems.
Social Learning Research
Ongoing research will focus on the participatory modeling process, involvement and learning, and will help shape design of subsequent project phases. Few studies systematically evaluate the nature of the exchange space that is created during similar PMP projects, and this research contribute to the broader knowledge of similar processes.
Understanding biases and appreciating others’ perspectives can be important to framing communication materials. Communication research will be implemented, and tools created to inform broader audiences of key issues, model scenarios and potential tradeoffs.
Stakeholder Engagement Team Members
Wendy-Lin Bartels, University of Florida
Lisette Staal, University of Florida